Product Details
A novel and exciting twist on a classic, Coop’s Peanut Butter Sauce has a clean label with no unnecessary additives or artificial ingredients. High-quality, recognizable ingredients that are thoughtfully selected.
01
Flavours
Warm, nutty, lightly sweet, rich, peanut-forward
02
Texture
Thick, spoonable, smooth, drizzly once warmed
03
Best For
Ice cream sundaes, brownies, pretzels, apple slices, shakes, dessert boards, sundae bars
Press & Awards
Best caramel sauce
Tasting Table (#1 ranked)
The Boston Globe, Today Show, Glamour, Elle, Rachael Ray
Featured in Food & Wine Best Food Gifts
Featured in BuzzFeed 2026
HOW TO USE
More Than Just a Topping
This liquid gold isn’t just made for ice cream—drizzle it over bananas, stir it into your smoothies and shakes, swirl it into your brownies or plunge your pretzels into it. Craving a double dose? Pair it with our rich, dark Coop’s Original Hot Fudge. The combinations are endless.
The Perfect Sundae Upgrade
For ice cream sundaes, Peanut Butter Sauce brings warmth, depth, and a creamy nutty finish that pairs beautifully with vanilla or chocolate ice cream. It’s an especially strong choice for a sundae bar because it feels a little unexpected while still being instantly recognizable and crowd-pleasing.
Made for Every Sweet Moment
A smart add-on for sundae kits, dessert gifts, and at-home sundae nights. Peanut Butter Sauce is the kind of flavor that makes a sundae spread feel a little more special without being fussy.
Pair it with Coop’s Original Hot Fudge for an extra-indulgent ice cream sundae, or add sprinkles and cookie crumbles for an easy sundae bar setup.
Peanut Butter Sauce texture and serving ideas
What is peanut butter sauce best used for?
Peanut Butter Sauce is delicious over ice cream sundaes, brownies, pretzels, apple slices, waffles, and shakes. Its thick, spoonable texture also makes it perfect for dessert boards and sundae bars.
Do I need to heat peanut butter sauce before serving?
You can enjoy it straight from the jar, but gently warming it brings out even more depth and makes it easier to drizzle over ice cream sundaes and other desserts.
What flavors pair well with peanut butter sauce?
It pairs especially well with vanilla and chocolate ice cream, bananas, pretzels, brownies, and Coop’s Original Hot Fudge for a richer sundae experience.
Is this good for a sundae bar or sundae kit?
Yes. Peanut Butter Sauce is a great choice for a sundae bar because it offers a familiar but slightly more special option alongside hot fudge and caramel. It also fits naturally into sundae kits built for sharing, gifting, or at-home sundae nights.
Do you mean sundae or "ice cream sunday"?
The correct dessert spelling is "ice cream sundae," though some people search for "ice cream sunday." Either way, this sauce was made for a great sundae.
Is Coop’s Peanut Butter Sauce all natural?
Yes. Coop’s Peanut Butter Sauce is made with five ingredients: peanuts, sugar, peanut oil, salt, and sunflower lecithin. No additives, no artificial ingredients, no preservatives.
What’s the difference between peanut butter sauce and regular peanut butter?
Peanut butter sauce is thinner and more drizzlable than regular peanut butter, especially when warmed. It’s formulated as a dessert topping—smoother, slightly sweeter, and designed to coat ice cream and other desserts rather than spread on bread.